One of [Sara Pennell’s] great strengths is her painstaking attempt to reconstruct ‘everyday’ plebeian and middling kitchens despite scant evidence. She accesses every type of source imaginable, including published accounts, diaries, letters, probate documents, court cases, deeds, ephemeral advertising, architectural and cookery books, illustrations, and literary sources … Pennell’s scholarship is not only impressive; her writing is accessible, elegant, and witty.