Trial on Trial: Volume 2

Antony Duff is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Stirling. Lindsay Farmer is Professor of Law at the University of Glasgow. Sandra Marshall is Professor of Philosophy in the University of Stirling. Victor Tadros is a Professor of Law at the University of Warwick.

• 1. Introduction: Judgment and Calling to AccountAntony Duff, Lindsay Farmer, Sandra Marshall, Victor Tadros2. Trial and ‘Fair Trial’: From Peer to Subject to CitizenMireille Hildebrandt3. Theorising Procedural Tradition: Subjects, Objects and Values in Criminal AdjudicationPaul Roberts4. The Trial and its Alternatives as Speech SituationsEvi Girling, Marion Smith and Richard Sparks5. ‘Who do you Think you Are?’ The Criminal Trial and Community CharacterSherman J Clark6. Theorising Jury ReformMike Redmayne7. It’s Good to Talk—Speaking Rights and the JuryBurkhard Schäfer and Olav K Wiegand8. Democratic Accountability and Lay Participation in Criminal TrialsTatjana Hörnle9. Judgment and Calling to Account: Truths, Trials and ReconciliationsScott Veitch10. The Political Trial and ReconciliationBert van Roermund11. Perpetrator Proceedings and Didactic TrialsLawrence Douglas12. Why have a Trial when you can have a Bargain?Thomas Weigend13. Conceptions of the Trial in Inquisitorial and Adversarial ProcedureJacqueline Hodgson14. Theorising the Criminal Trial and Criminal Appeal: Finality, Truth and RightsRichard Nobles and David Schiff

...offers a range of perspectives on an important issue...it encourages the reader to begin to unpick some received wisdoms concerning the assumed rationality and function of the trial process. Hannah Quirk British Journal of Criminology Vol. 47, No. 6, November 2007 The authors took me with them on their exciting quest, and some of the chapters really were exciting. Nicola Padfield The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, Vol 46, No 2 May-07 ...an enjoyable and difficult exercise in legal reasoning... a challenging read and I wholly recommend this series of books... Sally Ramage ...a most informative and varied analysis of the criminal trial...presents a huge variety of arguments and ideas on the nature, the theory and reality of the criminal trial. The profound, and in parts highly provocative, articles raise high expectations for the third volume of The Trial on Trial Sabine Swoboda Criminal Law Forum (2007) 18