'This is an extraordinarily insightful and thought-provoking book. Philip paints a breath-taking picture of the education system in Wales, shining a light into every corner of the system and down almost every corridor of power, before concluding that Wales has a seriously underperforming education system. Critically, however, Philip sets out his views about what now needs to be done, including how we encourage more 'heretics' throughout the system; people who will attempt to contest accepted orthodoxies, to stimulate debate and offer radically alternative approaches. We need look no further than this book to see how valuable this could be. Professor Chris Taylor, Cardiff University; 'An extraordinarily objective account of the state of Welsh education. There is no self-pitying, no lazy scapegoating, no intellectual 'huddling round a brazier' in this book. It is a frank and at times damning indictment of the policies and politicians who have allowed Wales to slide into education's international 'third division'. But it is fair, lucid and incredibly perceptive.';Gerard Kelly, Former Editor of the Times Educational Supplement