“In his conclusion to this careful study, John Baldovin acknowledges that the understanding of the ordered priesthood he soundly constructs through its fundamental relationship to church and sacrament has required attention to ‘difficult and delicate questions.’ Indeed so. And he has done so in admirably even-handed fashion. Baldovin’s approach—historical, doctrinal, pastoral—places him solidly in the lineage of the earlier Jesuit so instrumental to the liturgical renewal, Josef Jungmann, even as he commands contemporary advances in scholarship. The book is a genuine contribution toward realizing, in thought and practice, the assembly of the baptized as the active subject of the Eucharist and thus, priestly sacramental ministry as service to the people’s participation, as members of Christ’s Body, in the paschal mystery.”Bruce T. Morrill, SJ, Distinguished Professor of Theology, Vanderbilt University Divinity School