“The introduction of Revelation and Falsification is to be commended for the vast research and diversity of the sources consulted therein. It especially provides a good historical survey of the study of the Qurʿan by Western scholars. […] In the notes the authors have shown their full command and outstanding expertise on Shiʿa and Sunni sources of tafsir (exegesis) together with their meticulous research. […] All in all, Revelation and Falsification is a valuable contribution to the study of the Qurʿan and to creating a deeper understanding of the Shiʿa creed.”Mohammad Saeed Bahmanpour, in Journal of Shiʿa Islamic Studies, Spring 2010, Vol. III, No. 2.“This is a formidable work, erudite as much as it is meticulous. Moreover, it is a real advancement in knowledge for it is a critical edition of a rare and early work of Shiite religious literature. […] …what matters is the quality of the edition – with its critical apparatus and the indexes – that will become an exemplar for critical editions in the field for years to come.”Walid A. Saleh, in The Muslim World Book Review, 30:3, 2010."Magistralement éditée par E. Kohlberg […] et M.A. Amir-Moezzi […], imprimée avec tous les soins qu’une grande maison d’édition peut apporter, cette édition critique du Kitȃb al-qirȃʾȃt […] représente une importante contribution à la connaissance des controverses entre shȋʿites et sunnites à l’époque médiévale."J. Dean in Revue D’Histoire et de Philosophie Religieuses 2011, 91.1, p. 104.“This work […] is of remarkable quality. The critical edition is extremely well cared for. […] such a work is not simply useful but indeed necessary for any person who is interested in Qurʾānic exegesis.”Michel Lagarde in Islamochristiana 37 (2011), p.327-328.