An impressive book. -- Joel Relihan New England Classical Journal 2006 Weinbrot's prose is clear and sharp and witty. -- Cynthia Wall Studies in English Literature 2006 Weinbrot's impressive dissection of the Menippean branch will likely be viewed as a tour-de-force... among studies of satire. -- Kirk Combe 1650-1850: Ideas, Aesthetics and Inquiries 2007 This admirable study makes for the thoughtful taming of an otherwise intractable form, both in the weight that it brings to bear upon its separate arguments and in the care that it applies to their articulation. -- Timothy Erwin Modern Philology 2009 This book... offers a strong model for determining the canon and demands that future discussions proceed with care. -- Christopher Fanning Scriblerian 2008 Weinbrot... is a proven scholar [and] a genial and generous student of literature, well aware of the intellectual perils involved in working his way through such an argument. He is also breathtakingly learned. -- John J. Burke, Jr. Eighteenth-Century Life 2007