"In the introduction, McDonald argues that much current discourse around Chinese teaching and learning - the 'commonsense' axioms prevalent in Chinese studies today - needs to be problematized and reconsidered. To address this issue, McDonald has produced a response that is both theoretically rich yet generally accessible to a wider audience of students, teachers, and scholars. Speakers of Chinese (sinophones) and especially learners of Chinese will find this book particularly intriguing, given the intersecting linguistic, historical, sociocultural and narrative accounts that are presented. In the larger sense, McDonald has provided a compelling argument about the need to deconstruct the problems and contradictions that are inherent in modern Chinese language programs and textbooks." - Tim Anderson, Chinese Language and Discourse 2:1"I believe it to be an unusual and timely contribution to the field of Chinese Studies (or Sinology) and one that raises issues that will become increasingly critical as the reach of the “soft power” of the People’s Republic of China seeks to stretch to correspond with that nation’s burgeoning economic and political power." - Duncan M Campbell, The Australian National University; New Zealand Journal of Asian Studies 13, 1 (June 2011)