The Growth of the Medieval Icelandic Sagas (1180–1280) is both useful and thought-provoking throughout. Andersson's style is succinct and engaging. He introduces a number of basic concepts, which are clearly and useful explained, while still finding room for some striking, original, and challenging arguments.(Saga-Book) The very fact that one is drawn to engage with Andersson's saga criticism is a great strength of this book—there has never been enough committed, opinionated (in the most positive sense), intelligent, informed, and personal close reading of saga text. It is easily the best account to date of the origins of saga narrative.(Modern Language Review) Theodore M. Andersson has a fair claim to being the most important North American voice in saga scholarship, and this book is a stimulating, thoroughly informed, insightful, and thoughtful account of a representative set of sagas.(Journal of English and Germanic Philology)