"Rich with astute judgments about officers on each side, clearly written, and graced with excellent maps, Pfanz's book is tactical history at its finest." - Civil War; "A meticulous examination of the desperate engagements that over the course of the three days swept up and down the rough slopes of these two hills, the strategic anchors of the Union right flank." - New York Times Book Review; "[The] most comprehensive narrative yet written on this part of the battlefield...Civil War enthusiasts should clear a space on their bookshelf for Gettysburg - Culp's Hill and Cemetery Hill." - Blue and Gray