'The general subject needs detailed local studies of this sort to illuminate the wider picture and stimulate the posing of useful questions elsewhere. Early modern urban, military and social history will all benefit.' (Robert Higham, Senior Lecturer in Archaeology, University of Exeter) 'It will provide the most comprehensive study to date of the fortifications of an early modern English city. Its inclusion of transcripts of the very valuable information found in the city Receiver's Accounts, as well as some useful subsidiary documents, will be especially welcome. Such documentary detail is not available elsewhere, so both historians and military enthusiasts will benefit from being able to peruse transcripts of the original records.' (Maryanne Kowaleski, Professor of History, Fordham University, New York) '…the book’s significance lies in revealing how the medieval concept of the walled city remained active in the minds of 16th and 17th century Exonians as a symbol both of defence, civic pride and prestige.' (Andrew Saunders, Casemate, Jan 2004) ‘Mark Stoyle’s important volume, in presenting the first detailed account of the defences of an early modern English city (and indeed one of the most significant document-based studies of the defences of any British town) succeeds in overturning many………preconceptions’.‘A valuable scene-setting description of Exeter’s defensive topography emphasises that the city’s fortifications comprised far more than the wall and gates, but a multi-layered defensive belt stretching from an intra-mural route to the outer lip of the city ditch’ (Oliver Creighton, Sixteenth Century Journal) ‘…town defences have been something of the poor relations to castles. Mark Stoyle’s superb new book emphatically demonstrates that this need no longer be the case. Presenting a detailed yet lively social and military history of Exeter’s city walls in the Tudor and Early Stuart periods, Circled with Stone can be regarded as a major case study that will have a profound impact on our understanding of urban defences far beyond the city which it immediately deals.’ (Post Medieval Archaeology, Vol 38.2 for 2004) ‘The book is beautifully produced, with some superb colour plates of early modern maps of the city, and the main chapters are preceded by an immensely useful ‘tour’ of the walls. These qualities mean that it is attractive to many types of reader.’ (Post Medieval Archaeology, Vol 38.2 for 2004) ‘This attractively produced volume… The volume is both a labour of love by a citizen of Exeter who has become one of the most distinguished historians of the south west, and an act of homage to a friendship which crossed interdisciplinary lines. It is the fruit of historical scholarship and archaeological engagement.’ (Journal of Regional and Local Studies, 22.2: Spring 2003) 'Among the plates are an exceptional series of maps, reproduced in colour, which testify to the importance of the walls and to the pride which the leaders of the community retained in them.’ (Journal of Regional and Local Studies, 22.2: Spring 2003) ‘This volume does more than the modest claims of its author and publisher set out. They are to be congratulated on producing an important and attractive volume.’ (Journal of Regional and Local Studies, 22.2: Spring 2003) ‘This handsomely produced book comprises two major sections, a history of the city walls and a series of original documents … The book is beautifully and informatively illustrated … This is a social history of the walls which refracts the history of the community encircled by them.’ (History, Volume 90 Issue 1 Number 297 January 2005)
