Remarkably, Lockwood manages to offer something meaningful about the strengths and limitations of a vast literature of Beethoven biographies by German, Austrian, American, French, and British authors. With each biography, Lockwood tells us how (and if) a biography advances knowledge and understanding of Beethoven in its own time (and in some cases far beyond). Throughout, readers learn how biographers reflect the biases of their time and cultural milieu. . . . In short, Lockwood's brief but meaningful Lives seems to support the Latin adage upon which Beethoven based three musical canons: "Ars longa, vita brevis."