"[A] trenchant attempt to reorder the hierarchy... [Schell's] calculations produce a new all-time greatest hitter, revealed in sometimes breathless prose."--Joseph Kahn, New York Times "[Schell] has provided a wealth of baseball trivia and statistics. The style of writing is engaging and often lively and, in fact, encourages continued debate over the data and conclusions presented. The text will undoubtedly become a part of the baseball statistics fan's library."--Randall J. Swift, Mathematical Association of America Online Book Review "Buried deep within every true baseball fan is a nerd with a scorecard and a calculator... To refute those who say players from different eras can't be compared because they played in different circumstances, Schell levels the playing field by building models to account for those varying circumstances: ballparks, pitching quality, night games, etc... His conclusions are often surprising but well substantiated."--Booklist "[Schell] ranks current player Tony Gwynn as the best all-time hitter, well ahead of the modern batting king, Ted Williams, and no doubt outraging the ghosts of Ty Cobb and Babe Ruth... All in all, this book is for the hardcore baseball fan."--Library Journal "Altogether, a good read."--Earl Gutskey, The Los Angeles Times