“Xhignesse has a keen eye for how to pique the reader’s curiosity and is a succinct and even-handed surveyor of puzzles and their proposed resolutions. . . . Students are sure to respond to the vibrant prose and well chosen diet of issues from across aesthetics. . . . This is likely to make for a lively classroom and interesting term papers, and, whether or not instructors end up assigning this book, they will surely make use of it and find themselves cribbing Xhignesse’s punchy questions and concise summaries for their class discussion. It is a commendable achievement.” --Sam Cowling, Metascience