In keeping with Wittgensteins famous last proposition of the Tractatus, Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent, Santiáñezs readings of a constellation of First World War texts take us beyond the eras general ethical retreat into formal logic, where some ethical understanding may yet be possible in the figuration of silence itself. The premise of ethical silence dovetails exactly with much of the theory of PTSD narrative, in which the unspeakablewar trauma, rape, child or spousal abuse, wounding, torturebecomes quite unsayable and unwriteable. The essay is comprehensive and impeccable and has changed my thinking acutely on representations of war. - Philip Beidler, Margaret and William Going Professor of English, University of Alabama