Del 3 - Studies in Research Integrity

Subjectivities and Objectivities of Peer Review

Inbunden, Engelska, 2024

2 379 kr

Beställningsvara. Skickas inom 3-6 vardagar. Fri frakt för medlemmar vid köp för minst 249 kr.

“What do we want? Evidence-based science! When do we want it? After peer review!” We have come to think of peer review as the stamp of quality that separates real results from mere conjecture, but a look under the hood reveals that the participants inside of peer review are far from objective. This book reclaims subjectivity and affirms a social mode of objectivity, which prevents peer review from overpromising and underdelivering in its vital role in knowledge production.

Produktinformation

Utgivningsdatum2024-12-19
Mått155 x 235 x 16 mm
Vikt419 g
FormatInbunden
SpråkEngelska
SerieStudies in Research Integrity
Antal sidor164
FörlagBrill
ISBN9789004711365

Tillhör följande kategorier

Acknowledgments IXAbbreviations and Acronyms XIIntroduction: Peer Review, an Ancient New Tradition1 Introducing the Project1 How Peer Review Operates1 Agents and Their Roles2 Why Publish?3 The Referee Persona4 The Editor5 Schematic of the Peer Review Process6 Conclusion of Peer Review2 History1 The Myth of Oldenburg2 Pre-history of Peer Review3 Conclusion: Transition to Modern Peer Review3 Objectivity1 Objectivity as Realism2 Process Objectivity3 Persona4 Conclusion: Whither Objectivity?4 Anonymity1 What Is Anonymity?2 Rise of the Anonymous Referee3 Why Is Anonymity Accepted?4 Anonymous Authors5 Conclusion: the Tension between Anonymity and Open Science5 Trust1 A Cognitive Account of Trust2 The Hardwig Affair3 Peer Review and Trust4 The Replication Crisis5 Power Relations and Trust6 An Affective Account of Trust7 Expertise and Trust8 Trust and Distrust9 Conclusion on Trust in Peer Review6 Opening Up1 Opening Peer Review2 Opening Access3 Conclusion on OpennessConclusionBibliographyIndex