Shaping Identities in a Holy Land

Gil Fishhof teaches medieval and Crusader art at the Department of Art History, University of Haifa. His main areas of expertise are Romanesque art and architecture in France, art in the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, art of the Cluniac order, and questions of medieval patronage and audiences. Together with Einat Segal and Assaf Pinkus he has recently published the edited volume The Basilica of the Annunciation in Nazareth - Where the Word became Flesh (2020), and with Vardit Shoten-Hallel and Judith Bronstein the volume Settlement and Crusade in the 13th Century - Multidisciplinary Studies of the Latin East (2021).

• Introduction / 1. The Historiography of Crusader Art Revisited: Conceptions and Revolutions / 2. Glorious Past(s) – Tradition, Living-Memory and the Construction of Legitimacy / 3. Holy Sites: Pilgrims, Prestige and Competition / 4. The Image of the Muslim in the Art of the Latin Kingdom – Between Ideology, Demonization and Encounter / 5. Eastern Christians, Byzantine Style and the Pictorial Language of Crusader Art / 6. The Complexities of Patronage / Conclusion – Crusader Art as a Multilayered System

‘Part synthesis, part original thesis, teeming with new ideas, and reconsidering old orthodoxies, Shaping Identities in a Holy Land is an inspirational piece of work demonstrating a great deal of reflection and research. Fishhof is especially strong when placing specific pieces of artwork or architectural features in their contemporary context, identifying the moulding influence of contemporary concerns and ambitions. His thesis that a culture of “flexibility” represents the Frankish artistic project is likewise highly illuminating. Historians have traditionally defined Eastern Frankish culture as driven by dogmatic inflexibility and a brutal indifference or hostility towards other cultures; this stands starkly in contradistinction to the far more flexible and negotiated model offered by Fishhof’ - Al-Masāq, 36:2.‘This researcher, in his exceptional way, examines in his new book the existing studies in the field of Crusader art. Fishhof 's book offers a new and original interpretation of those medieval sites where Crusader elements appear in the cities of Jerusalem, Bethlehem and Nazareth, in impressive Crusader churches, and remaining as prominent sites of that period, such as the Church of the Holy Sepulchre and the Church of Emmaus in Abu-Ghosh’ - Ordines Militares, XXIX 2024.‘… an important, interesting, and thoroughly engaging work’ – Crusades, 23:2.