"The book is a fine collection of twelve essays on several second-century texts and their relation to the Fourth Gospel. The editor mentions in the very dense introduction the need to ‘abandon the old division between “orthodox” and “heterodox” forms of Christianity as misleading and anachronistic. [...]All in all, this is indeed an exciting volume, which offers a wealth of information and stimulating discussions on the relation of the Fourth Gospel to indeed a large spectrum of second-century texts. Equipped with a learned introduction from the editor and three indices at the end, it is surely a useful instrument for all who are looking for different perspectives on the presence of John in the second century." – Dan Batovici (full review)"Ce recueil de textes est d’une très grande qualité, ce qui n’est guère surprenant lorsque nous prenons connaissance des auteurs qui y ont contribué. ... Cet ouvrage donne ... un très bon aperçu de l’étendue de l’influence du quatrième Évangile au deuxième siècle." – Steve Johnston, in: Laval théologique et philosophique"Dieser Band ... zeigt eine Vielzahl von aktuellen Forschungsfeldern auf und bietet, davon ausgehend, eine Reihe von Denkanstößen. Darin ist sicherlich seine große Stärke zu sehen." – Stephan Witetschek, in: Biblische Zeitschrift 55/2011-2"There is much good scholarship and accurate reasoning in this [volume]." – M.J. Edwards, Christ Church, Oxford, in: Journal of Theological Studies, October 2013