Owing equal parts to deconstruction and to political theory, and situated halfway between US Americanism and Latin Americanism, Counterfeit Politics is a rare book . . . Such a variety of registers will constitute an asset [to readers]. This review is of the opinion that the work is a valuable contribution to hemispheric literary studies. . . .The many merits of the book include, of course, its valiant position at the crossroads of different sub-fields. Kelman takes a stand against the academic market sanctioned practice of disciplinary over-specialization, which often leads to the balkanization of literary archives that belong together. Piglia reading Hemingway, Borges reading English-language detective fiction, or conversely, Borges influencing US postmodernism are all examples of the viability and importance of comparative work. Moreover, Kelman does high theory at a time when many critics have abandoned the ship. For these reasons alone, he is to be commended.