Sheffield's analysis of the unfolding of these successive images on the whole is persuasive. While his interpretation, as he forthrightly acknowledges, is "in several respects similar (10)" to Ronald Haycock's The Image of the Indian, Sheffield's research is more systematic and his argument more fine-grained ... The Red Man's on the Warpath is an important contribution to our understanding of both domestic attitudes towards First Nations and the impact of external events upon those views. - JR Miller, University of Saskatchewan (International Journal, Autumn 2005) Subtle, interesting book ... It is a mark of the quality of this book that it stimulates such broad questions, while satisfying our curiousity about a particular phase of Canadian history. - James M. Pitsula, University of Regina (Labour/Le Travail, Issue 58, Fall 2005) Sheffield's exploration of this time period, an often-overlooked era in Canadian Aboriginal history, his "holistic" use of newspapers to access images of First Nations people held by the dominant society, combined with his detailed, yet readable argument, makes an important contribution to the twentieth-century historiography of Canadian Aborgininal people. - Robert Alexander Innes, American Indian Studies Program, Michigan State University (Great Plains Quarterly, Spring 2006) Sheffield's task is monumental and, accordingly, the scope of his documentary analysis is impressive ... Sheffield has clearly made a valuable contribution of an underdeveloped area of scholarship. He has laid the pioneering framework for future work that will, I hope, fill in the remaining gaps ... - Madelaine Jacobs (Canadian Literature, Spring 2006)