Earle weaves together a history of numerous and complex moving parts that include diplomats and statesmen alongside naval officers and fishermen while also bringing in natural scientist and industry leaders, all while bridging the Atlantic borderlands with Americans, Canadians, and British actors. Its greatest contribution is to diplomatic history and the history of American national identity in the Early Republic. This book is, I think, the best answer we've seen to why historians need to pay more attention to fisheries history.(The Northern Mariner) This scholarly intervention will be most compelling to environmental historians as the field continues to grapple with the confounding relationships between industries, state actors, the roots of ecological destruction, and the policies that might prevent such devastation in the future.(H-Net) Meticulously researched, The Liberty to Take Fish is highly instructive in its careful use of relevant archival sources, both physical and human, to determine how historical actors understood environmental conditions.(American Historical Review) Earle's prose is energetic and engaging.(H-Net)