Inland Navigation System Planning

In 1988, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers began an investigation of the benefits and costs of extending several locks on the lower portion of the Upper Mississippi River-Illinois Waterway (UMR-IWW) in order to relieve increasing waterway congestion, particularly for grain moving to New Orleans for export. With passage of the Flood Control Act of 1936, Congress required that the Corps conduct a benefit-cost analysis as part of its water resources project planning; Congress will fund water resources projects only if a project's benefits exceed its costs. As economic analysis generally, and benefit-cost analysis in particular, has become more sophisticated, and as environmental and social considerations and analysis have become more important, Corps planning studies have grown in size and complexity. The difficulty in commensurating market and nonmarket costs and benefits also presents the Corps with a significant challenge. The Corps' analysis of the UMR-IWW has extended over a decade, has cost roughly $50 million, and has involved consultations with other federal agencies, state conservation agencies, and local citizens. The analysis has included many consultants and has produced dozens of reports.In February 2000, the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) requested that the National Academies review the Corps' final feasibility report. After discussions and negotiations with DOD, in April 2000 the National Academies launched this review and appointed an expert committee to carry it out.Table of ContentsFront MatterExecutive SummaryIntroductionThe Public Interest in the Upper Mississippi RiverU.S. Federal and Corps of Engineers Water Resources Planning GuidelinesThe Navigation Feasability StudyImproving Waterway System PlanningSummary and RecommendationsReferencesAppendix A: Participating Agencies in the Corps' 1991 Plan of StudyAppendix B: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Executive Summary for the Corps of Engineers System Navigation StudyAppendix C: Tradable Lockage PermitsAppendix D: Biographical Sketches of Committee Members