Can the criminal justice system achieve justice based on its ability to determine the truth? Drawing on a variety of disciplinary and interdisciplinary perspectives, this book investigates the concept of truth – its complexities and nuances – and scrutinizes how well the criminal justice process facilitates truth-finding. From allegation to sentencing, the chapters take the reader on a journey through the criminal justice system, exposing the marginalization of truth-finding in favour of other jurisprudential or systemic values, such as expediency, procedural fairness and the presumption of innocence.This important work bridges the gap between what people expect from the criminal justice system and what it can legitimately deliver.
Gavin Dingwall is Professor of Criminal Justice Policy at De Montfort University.Tim Hillier is Head of the School of Law at De Montfort University.
The Criminal Process and the Pursuit of TruthAllegationsConfessionsWitness TestimonyTruth and the Probity of Evidence-GatheringDecisions and Narratives: Factfinding and Case ConstructionTruth and the Criminal Trial: Competing StoriesTruth, Sentencing and PunishmentRestoration, Reconciliation and Reconceptualizing JusticeThe Truth, the Whole Truth and Nothing but the Truth: The Truth of Who Is to Blame