[This] exhaustive analysis...shows how alienation of the worker from the soil led to an exploitation that continues to this day, a socioeconomic interpretation of history largely neglected by the historians. Thus the work of this economist and economic historian is a model of social science research...Dr. Jaynes has produced a work which not only illustrates the highest performance and the extraordinary promise of ethnocentric specialization, but represents a major contribution to the effort to bring the social sciences into closer touch with the reality of a dynamically changing society. American Journal of Economics and Sociology Makes a valuable contribution to understanding the slaves' passage from bondage to the free working class. Journal of Interdisciplinary History If this book did no more than show that the South's underdeveloped capital markets were preconditions for economic failure, it would be a very good book indeed. But Jaynes accomplishes much more...He has read widely in the literature on slavery and emancipation and mined the exhaustive records of the Freedman's Bureau. Economic shrewdness is mixed with common sense. His book thus carries authority...A very good book, maybe a seminal one in the history of the black working class in the South during its early years of freedom. It deserves the widest possible readership. American Historical Review A highly significant book. Journal of Social History An insightful and original analysis of the transition from slavery to freedom and its effects on the southern economy. Journal of Southern History An extraordinary contribution...brilliant in its insightful and sensitive use of literary and statistical evidence, in its application of quantitative methods to clarify rather than obscure, in its reach to analytical models drawn from other cultures, both ancient and modern, and in its shrewd handling of historiographical issues. Choice A model of social science research...a major contribution toward ending historians' debates over central issues of the Reconstruction. American Journal of Economics and Sociology [An] original and provocative reinterpretation...Those who want to ponder the real economic meaning of freedom for American blacks will find Branches Without Roots indispensable. Journal of Economic Literature Branches Without Roots has greatly enhanced my understanding of what was really happening during the process of Reconstruction. [It] show[s] with rich detail the nature of the material and intellectual environment in which the emancipated slaves were expected to make their way. David B. Davis, Yale University A most impressive piece of scholarship. It is really a major step forward in an important debate and will have a big impact on subsequent scholars. Stanley L. Engerman, University of Rochester Sophisticated...Integrates social, political, and economic lines of inquiry adeptly and interestingly...Branches Without Roots sparkles with original thoughts about an old topic, and will become a standard in the field. Georgia Historical Quarterly [An] informative and well-researched monograph. The Historian
