Recognition has become one of the key concepts of contemporary critical theory, heralded by thinkers such as Axel Honneth and Charles Taylor. It is widely claimed that a person must be recognized by others in order to realize their own identity and that the lack of recognition constitutes a form of oppression or injustice. Is recognition always a good thing?In this ambitious and compelling book, Kristina Lepold challenges the common assumption that recognition is positive, emphasizing its ambivalent role in social life. She offers a systematic account of the complex nature of recognition, showing how it can implicate us in oppressive or otherwise problematic arrangements. Lepold engages with different approaches for thinking about recognition—including Axel Honneth’s influential theory, as well as arguments made by Louis Althusser, Pierre Bourdieu, and Judith Butler—which she reconstructs in a nuanced and accessible fashion.By one of the most original voices in the new generation of critical theorists, Ambivalent Recognition is a must-read for anyone interested in not only one of critical theory’s key concepts but also the larger question of why unjust social arrangements often prove so stubborn and difficult to change.
Kristina Lepold is junior professor of social philosophy and critical theory at Humboldt University Berlin and an associated member of the Center for Social Critique.Ciaran Cronin has translated numerous works of political philosophy and social theory by prominent authors including Jürgen Habermas and Rainer Forst.Martin Saar is professor of social philosophy at Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main.
Foreword, by Martin SaarAcknowledgmentsIntroduction1. The Context of Honneth’s Theory of Recognition2. The Foundations of Honneth’s Theory of Recognition3. The Struggle for Recognition4. Althusser and the Reproduction of the Social Order5. Bourdieu and the Reproduction of Social Inequality6. Butler and the Reproduction of Binary Gender Normality7. Ambivalent RecognitionNotesReferencesIndex
Ambivalent Recognition is an impressive first book by Kristina Lepold, one of the most exciting voices of a new generation of critical theorists. She argues, convincingly, that we should see recognition—usually thought of as something positive—as ambivalent, for it can make us complicit in problematic social arrangements.