Park-Ozee and Jordan deftly distill today’s fervent legal, political, and media debates surrounding the status of trans athletes to the essential core issue: fairness. The authors expose how the transphobic playbook effectively weaponizes rhetorics of fairness to marginalize trans athletes under the guise of defending women’s sports. This timely book is a critical and necessary reminder in an era fraught with doublespeak, that which is deemed fair can be unfair, and that we must remain vigilant against protectionist rhetoric that undermines genuine gender equity in sport.