The work stands as a testament to [the editor's] diligent scholarship [...] Clearly this is highly relevant to anyone specifically studying the history of Newcastle and the North East, but the interest engendered by the approach could be much wider. The editorial method (including the expansion of abbreviations, addition of punctuation and supply of omitted words) makes the source evidence easily accessible to those without paleographic experience and the introduction could stand alone as a brief, informative survey. As a result, the readership could include those interested in various areas of history: industrial (especially industrial relations, and the role of local and central government), economic, class, charity, legal and maritime amongst them.