�... (an) excellent biography ...a fascinating read that is anything but dull.� The Delian �Beale�s comprehensive and thoroughly researched biography sheds new light on Hall�nd the musical life of nineteenth-century Manchester. With his painstaking research, he presents the most complete picture of Hall�nd a richer understanding of his failures, his successes, and the problems he faced. Even more, this study fills a large gap in the growing research on the evolution of the modern orchestra and concert life in Great Britain and beyond.� NABMSA Newsletter �Beale�s contribution to our understanding of not just Hall� career but also the working conditions of his �band� is strong in its careful analysis of data. This is a useful book which adds to our understanding of Hall� dual-marketplace career and enduring legacy.� Journal of the Society for Musicology in Ireland